|
Poor Indoor Air Quality can arise from many
types of air contaminants arising from many sources. In office buildings,
they can be classified into three groups, that are gases and vapours,
such as CO, from people, butyric acid from roads and highways, CO
from adjacent parking lots, tobacco smoke, VOCs from paints, wood
panelling, office equipment, formaldehyde from carpeting and furnishings.
Another source is inert particles like dust and man made fibres
and thirdly micro-organisms like fungus, bacteria, virus and molds
resulting from high humidity and damp corners.
Inadequate maintenance of the HVAC system,
can become a breeding ground for most of the pollutants and inadequate
ventilation leads to, a concentration of pollutants indoors.
There can be two basic solutions to improving
the indoor air quality.
Source Control
Pollutants Removal
a. Ventilation
b. Air Cleaning
Source Control, though a preferred approach,
may not often be practical. Source control measures are pollutant
specific and may include use of low formaldehyde emitting
materials, banning of cigarette smoking, prevention of radon entry
through sealing of foundations, eliminating use of asbestos and
storing of paints and chemicals outside the occupied space. Controlling
of relative humidity will prevent the growth of mold, mildew and
microbial contaminations. Routine or regular maintenance of HVAC
system
is another method of reducing the pollutant level.
Air cleaning is the second method of
removal of pollutants. It is not a substitute for fresh outside
air. Air filters, ionizers and electrostatic precipitators can effectively
rid indoor air of some microscopic particles such as dust and some
smoke, but they do not totally purify and revitalize the air. These
devices must be sized and maintained properly in order to work effectively.
An advantage of some air cleaners is their
ability to remove some particles such as pollen, that originate
outside. A disadvantage is that they have no effect at all on the
concentration of some pollutants such as formaldehyde, carbon monoxide
and other gases.
Ventilation is the natural movement
of air through a building. Removal of contaminants from a building
or reducing its concentration within a work space can be accomplished
by
either passive or active ventilation.
Passive ventilation refers to infiltration
/ exfiltration or the air exchanged through doors, windows or other
openings by natural forces. In most airconditioned buildings, these
openings have been reduced to the minimum to conserve energy. Active
ventilation systems provide continuous ventilation through windows.
Regular ventilation not only provides a sufficient supply of oxygen
but unavoidable pollutants, contaminants and unpleasant odours.
Sufficient ventilation, especially in summer
can prevent excessive humidity. In places where ventilation through
the windows is not always possible, mechanical ventilation is
used.
Mechanical ventilation is the airflow out of
and into a building resulting from pressure differences caused by
fans or blowers.
Unfortunately, what we call, fresh outdoor
air is not so fresh any more, but quite polluted. Under such circumstances,
ventilation though the most important method alone will not suffice
as the main measure for improving indoor air, but a combination
of source control, filtration, air cleaning and ventilation provides
the ideal mix for improving indoor air quality.
"The Solution to Pollution is
Dilution"
This is an age old dictum, the practice of
which was given up by building owners in the wake of energy conservation,
by making tighter buildings.
Dilution refers to ventilation with outdoor
air, to reduce the concentration of pollutants in a room or building.
However, in recent times with growing indoor air quality problems
and its effect on the health of the occupants, it was discovered
that the ventilation standards
designed to dilute the pollutants were found to be insufficient.
Air enters a building in three ways infiltration, natural ventilation
and mechanical ventilation. Outdoor air mixes with indoor air and
reduces the concentration of pollutants.
The rate at which outside air replaces indoor
air is described as the air exchange rate. When there is little
infiltration, natural ventilation or mechanical ventilation, the
air exchange rate is low and pollutant levels can increase.
In fact as the figure overleaf shows, the dilution
principle says that the concentration of pollution is inversely
proportional to the ventilation rate.
The air exchange rate of average buildings today
is 2 air changes per hour. In tight buildings air changes per hour
is as low as .2 to .3. In leaky buildings it can be as much as 3
air changes per hour.
It is important to understand that an air exchange
rate of 1 air exchange per hour does not mean that all pollutants
will be removed is one hour, but that with 2 to 3 air changes per
hour the concentration of pollutants will be low.
Ventilation is a process of dilution and removal
that gradually gets rid of pollutants. In addition, pollutant removal
is further slowed down by the fact that some pollutants are trapped
by carpets, drapes and other surfaces only to be released into the
air later.
An existing ventilation system which is inadequate
because of design flows, poor maintenance or expanded use of a building
will often be associated with poor indoor air quality. Redesign
or maintenance of HVAC system may be required.
The remedy for IAQ problems thus becomes obvious
- Increase Ventilation
Increased Ventilation Standard vs. Energy
Management
The Challenge !
As the recommended levels of outside air brought
into the conditioned space has been increased by 3 times (to 25.5
CMH (15 CFM) from 8.5 CMH (5 CFM) per person) much higher latent
and sensible loads are imposed on the cooling and heating equipment.
Introduction of even a small quantity of air
into an HVAC system raises physical plant requirements dramatically,
creating a need for balancing energy needs with the IAQ standard.
The challenge before the designers and contractors,
is to design HVAC systems in buildings, restaurants and hospitals
tor an improved indoor environment at no extra utility bills for
the owners.
A challenge yes! but impossible - No! with
options for effective energy recovery equipment available.
Ashrae62-2001.1AQ Standard
"Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality"
In the HVAC industry, ASHRAE American Society of Heating, Refrigeration
and Ventilating Engineers) plays a leadership role in research and
setting standards.
The ASHRAE standard for acceptable indoor air
quality specifiesminimum ventilation rates that will be acceptable
to human occupants and are intended to avoid adverse health effects.
The standard 62-1999 recommends fresh air intake of 25.5 TO 34 CMH
(15 to 20 CFM) per person where 8.5 CMH (5 CFM) was considered adequate
by the industry. CO2 levels, which have
been recognized by ASHRAE as the surrogate ventilation index (being
the only economically and practically measurable variable) should
not exceed 1000 ppm.
|
Regulations and Guidelines pertaining to IAQ
|
| Regulatory Body |
Country |
Standard |
Ventilation |
CO2 (not exceeding) |
| OSHA |
US |
29 CFR
1910.1033
(Proposed) |
|
800 ppm |
| ASHRAE |
US |
62-1999 |
25.5 CMH (15 CFM)/ person
34 CMH (20 CFM)/ person
7 people/1000 ft2 |
1000 ppm |
| |
Codes for new homes/construction |
| NBCC |
Canada
Sweden
France
Japan |
|
0.5 AC/HR
0.5 AC/HR
0.5 AC/HR
25.5 CMH (15 CFM) /person |
1000 ppm
1000 ppm
1000 ppm
1000 ppm |
|
|